Where to Eat

Where to Eat In Cooperstown Area

All addresses listed are Cooperstown,  NY  13326 unless otherwise noted.

Alex and Ika
149 Main Street – (607)547-4070
One of the “Top Ten Restaurants in NYS” Frommer’s 2000. Visit us atwww.alexandika.com.

American Hotel
PO Box 121, Sharon Springs, NY 13459
Location: Main Street, Route 10 North, Sharon Springs, NY 13459 – (518)284-2105
“Highly Recommended” Fodor’s 2005 Travel Guide

The Bean
17 Commons Drive – (607)544-9999

Black Cat Cafe & Bakery
PO Box 400 , Sharon Srings, NY 13459
Location: 195 Main Street, Sharon Springs, NY 13459 – (518)284-2575
Café Bakery in historic Sharon Springs. Serving Breakfast & Lunch. Cakes, Parties, Weddings and Cooking Classes.

The Blue Mingo Grill
6098 St Hwy 80 – (607)547-7496

The Bullpen
43 Pioneer Street – (607)547-1800

Christophers Restaurant & Country Lodge
4158 St Hwy 23, Oneonta, NY 13820
Location: St Hwy 28 Oneonta, NY  13820 – (607)432-2444

Cooley’s Stone House Tavern
49 Pioneer Street – (607)544-1311

Cooperstown Diner
136 1/2 Main Street – (607)547-9201
Open 6am – 8pm everyday (Summer till 9pm). Serving breakfast till closing. Try our JUMBO burgers! Nightly Dinner Specials.

Cooperstown Farmers’ Market/Otsego 2000 
PO Box 1130
Location: 101 Main Street, Pioneer Alley – (607)547-8881

Danny’s Main Street Market
92 Main Street – (607)547-4053

Depot Deli
21 Railroad Avenue – (607)547-7130

DiMaggios Cooperstown Hot Dog
4561 St Hwy 28, Milford, NY 13807 – (607)547-5400
A family restaurant serving regional style hotdogs, sandwiches, ice cream and real Italian Ices.

The Doubleday Café
93 Main Street – (607)547-5468

The Farmers’ Museum
PO Box 30
Location: St Hwy 80 Lake Road – (607)547-1450

The Farmhouse Restaurant
4158 St Hwy 23, Oneonta, NY 13820
Location: St Hwy 7, Oneonta, NY 13820 – (607)432-7374

Fenimore Art Museum/NYSHA
PO Box 800
Location: St Hwy 80 Lake Road – (888)547-1450

Hoffman Lane Bistro
2 Hoffman Lane – (607)547-7055

Italian Kitchen
58-60 Market Street, Oneonta, NY 13820
Location: 66 Church Street, Oneonta, NY 13820 – (607)432-2776

Jackie’s Restaurant
3688 St Hwy 28, Milford, NY 13807 – (607)286-7843

K-C’s Corner Motel & Restaurant
5705 St Hwy 20, East Springfield, NY 13333 – (607)264-9392

La Tarantella
6181 St Hwy 7, Oneonta, NY 13820 – (607)432-1166
Trattoria & Pizzeria. “Home Cooking Sicilian Cuisine” Everything prepared by the order. Brick oven pizza. Private room available for any occasion.

Lake Front Motel & Restaurant 
10 Fair Street – (607)547-9511
Located in the village of Cooperstown on beautiful Otsego Lake, just one block from Baseball Hall of Fame.

Main Street Kitchen and Lounge
161 Main Street – (607)547-6106
Creative seasonal cuisine in the heart of Cooperstown. Hip lounge with unique cocktails.

Mama’s Kitchen
3810 St Rte 33, Cherry Valley, NY 13320
Location: 3220 St Hwy 166, Roseboom, NY 13450 – (607)264-3118
Open Sun-Wed 7am-2pm, Thurs-Sat 7am- 9pm. Prime Rib special Friday nights.

McDonald’s of Cooperstown
4 Wells Street, Johnstown, NY 12095
Location: 60 Commons Drive, Cooperstown, NY 13326 – (607)547-1110

Nicoletta’s Italian Cafe
96 Main Street – (607)547-7499

O’Hanlans Steakhouse
18 Commons Drive – (607)544-1401

The Otesaga Resort Hotel
PO Box 311
Location: 60 Lake Street, Route 80 – (800)348-6222

The Penguin
PO Box 104 , Walton, NY 13856 ; 4833 St Hwy 28 – (607)267-6353

Pepper Mill
5418 St Hwy 28 – (607)547-8550

Pops Place
4347 St Hwy 28, Milford, NY 13807 – (607)286-7219

Portabello’s
6027 St Hwy 28, Fly Creek, NY 13337 – (607)547-5145
Portabello’s, open 365 days a year, is your home away from home at the busy 4 corners in Fly Creek.

Remember When Cafe, Antiques and Guest House
34 North Main Street , New Berlin, NY  13411 – (607)847-9799
Stay in New Berlin’s beautifully renovated old hospital, with victorian cafe and antique shop in the building. Outdoor dining available. Visit our website at www.rememberwhenguesthouse.com or email us rememberwhengh@frontiernet.net.

The Rose & Kettle
PO Box 73 , Cherry Valley, NY 13320
Location: 4 Lancaster Street, Cherry Valley, NY  13320 – (607)264-3078

Sabatini’s Little Italy Restaurant & Villa 
4158 St Hwy 23, Oneonta, NY 13820 – (607)432-3000

Sal’s Pizzeria and Restaurant
110 Main Street – (607)547-5721

The Short Stop Restaurant
74 Main Street – (607)547-9609

Stella Luna Ristorante’
58-60 Market Street, Oneonta, NY 13820 – (607)433-7646

Stewart’s Shops
PO Box 435, Saratoga Springs, NY 12866
Location: 108 Chestnut Street – (607)547-7248

SweetTooth SchoolHouse, Inc.
PO Box 1603 , Richfield Springs, NY 13934
Location: 540 St Hwy 165, Pleasant Brook – (607)264-3233

Tino’s Pizza
75 Chestnut Street – (607)547-2930
Check out our daily lunch specials. Just a short distance from Main Street. It’s well worth the walk! Homemade Italian-American specialties! Closed Sundays.

Townsend Catering at Templeton Hall Banquet Facility
63 Pioneer Street – (607)547-8877
Templeton Hall banquet facility holds up to 125 people for functions including breakfast, lunch and dinner as well as meetings.

Triple Play Cafe
64 Main Street – (607)547-1395

The Tunnicliff Inn, Cooperstown
34 Pioneer Street – (607)547-9611
One minute’s walk to the Baseball Hall of Fame, 498 feet away. In the center of downtown Cooperstown.

The Village Tower
102 Chestnut Street – (607)547-5570

Villa Isidoro
3941 St Hwy 20, Richfield Springs, NY 13439 – (315)858-3500
Spectacular 1790′s stone mansion located north of Cooperstown offering two different dining venues. Fine dining featuring authentic and award winning cuisine and a rustic tavern offering a more casual menu with wood-fired gourmet pizzas.

Winnie’s Catering
38 Elm Street – (607)547-5782

Yum Yum Shack
4918 St Hwy 28 – (607)547-8088