Where to Eat

Where to Eat In Cooperstown Area

All addresses listed are Cooperstown,  NY  13326 unless otherwise noted.

Bocca Osteria
5438 State Highway 28
(607) 282-4031

Cantina de Salsa
149 Main St.
(607) 547-4070

The Jive Cafe
17 Commons Drive #17
(607) 544-9999

Black Cat Cafe & Bakery
195 Main St., Sharon Springs, NY 13459
(518) 284-2575

The Blue Mingo Grill
6098 St Hwy 80
(607) 547-7496

Christophers Restaurant & Country Lodge
St Hwy 28 Oneonta, NY  13820
(607) 432-2444

Cooley’s Stone House Tavern
49 Pioneer St.
(607) 544-1311

Cooperstown Back Alley Grill
8 Hoffman Lane
(607) 322-4048

Cooperstown Diner
136 1/2 Main Street
(607) 547-9201

Cooperstown Farmers’ Market/Otsego 2000
101 Main St., Pioneer Alley
(607) 547-8881

The Cooperstown Penguin Ice Cream
4833 State Highway 28
(607) 282-4339

Council Rock Brewery
4861 State Highway 28
(607) 643-3016

Danny’s Main Street Market
92 Main St.
(607) 547-4053

The Doubleday Café
93 Main St.
(607)547-5468

The Farmers’ Museum Crossroads Cafe
St Hwy 80 -Lake Road
(607) 547-1450

The Farmhouse Restaurant
4158 St Hwy 23, Oneonta, NY 13820
(607) 432-7374

Fenimore Art Museum – Fenimore Cafe
St Hwy 80 – Lake Road
(888) 547-1450

The Hawkeye Bar and Grill
The Otesaga Resort Hotel
60 Lake St.
(607) 547-9931

Jackie’s Restaurant
3688 State Highway 28, Milford, NY 13807
(607) 286-7843

KC’s Corner Motel & Restaurant
5705 St Hwy 20, East Springfield, NY 13333
(607) 264-9392

Lake Front Motel & Restaurant
10 Fair Street
(607) 547-9511

McDonald’s of Cooperstown
60 Commons Drive
(607) 547-1110

Mel’s at 22
22 Chestnut St.
(607) 435-7062

New York Pizzeria
75 Chestnut St.
(607) 547-2930

Nicoletta’s Italian Cafe
96 Main St.
(607) 547-7499

Origins Cafe
558 Beaver Meadow Rd.
(607) 437-2862

The Otesaga Resort Hotel
60 Lake Street, Route 80
(800) 348-6222

Pops Place
4347 St Hwy 28, Milford, NY 13807
(607) 286-7219

Portabello’s
6027 St Hwy 28, Fly Creek, NY 13337
(607) 547-5145

The Red Caboose Restaurant and Bar
214 Main St., Oneonta, NY 13820
(607) 267-4966

The Rose & Kettle
4 Lancaster St., Cherry Valley, NY  13320
(607) 264-3078

Sabatini’s Little Italy Restaurant & Villa
4158 St Hwy 23, Oneonta, NY 13820
(607)432-3000

Sal’s Pizzeria and Restaurant
110 Main St.
(607) 547-5721

Schneider’s Bakery
157 Main St.
(607) 547-9631

Stagecoach Coffee
31 Pioneer St.
(607) 547-6229

Stella Luna Ristorante
58-60 Market St., Oneonta, NY 13820
(607) 433-7646

Stewart’s Shops Ice Cream
108 Chestnut St.
(607) 547-7248

Toscana Northern Italian Grill
64 Main St.
(607) 547-2100

The Tunnicliff Inn, Cooperstown
34 Pioneer St.
(607) 547-9611

The Shack
4918 St Hwy 28
(607) 547-8088